Our range of services in trademark law

We advise and support you in all legal matters, from the design of your trademark (choice of words, graphic design) to the clearance search and registration with the trademark authority. From then on, we monitor your trademark on request, after agreeing on the type and scope of this monitoring in advance.

We defend your trademark against attacks by third parties before the trademark authorities and the competent courts.

We have been representing more than 100 trademarks before various trademark authorities for more than two decades.

Frequently asked questions about trademarks

A registered trademark gives its owner the exclusive right to use the trademark in connection with the goods and/or services for which the trademark is registered. Third parties may not use identical or similar signs for the same or related goods/services. Trademarks can be licensed, sold, or pledged. The owner can take action against trademark infringements by issuing warnings, injunctions, and claims for damages. Registration provides legal protection for a trademark and gives it a high value as a distinguishing feature of a company or product.

We have compiled a list of frequently asked questions about trademarks with concise answers:

A registered trademark gives its owner the exclusive right to use the trademark in connection with the goods and/or services for which the trademark is registered.

A trademark therefore requires a distinctive sign. This refers only to signs that are capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one company from those of other companies.

The trademark serves to distinguish the goods or services of one company from those of another company (source function of the trademark).

A trademark does not necessarily come into existence solely through registration in the relevant trademark register. In principle, it can also come into existence through the mere use of the relevant sign. Such a trademark exists when the relevant distinguishing feature is clearly associated with a specific company by the relevant public. However, the burden of proof lies with the party invoking this type of trademark. This is usually done by means of a survey conducted by opinion research institutes or other experts. The costs involved are immense.

The owner of a trademark can also grant a right to use their trademark. This is done by means of a trademark license.

A registered trademark can be renewed indefinitely. It can, so to speak, live forever. However, the trademark will be deleted if the renewal fee is not paid after the expiry of the respective term of protection of the relevant register.

The trademark authorities check trademark applications for absolute grounds for refusal. Absolute grounds for refusal include, for example:

  • lack of distinctive character
  • descriptive indications that must be kept free for general use
  • a national emblem contained in the trademark
  • contravention of morality or public order

In addition to signs that are not clearly and unambiguously identifiable, signs that lack any distinctive character or merely describe the goods and services in question are excluded from protection.

Since 1 January 2021, EU trademarks no longer have effect in the United Kingdom. Until the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020, they remained valid there (Articles 126 and 127 of the Withdrawal Agreement).

For every EU trademark registered by that date, the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) automatically created a corresponding UK trademark free of charge on 1 January 2021, known as a “comparable trademark (EU)” (Article 54(1)(a) of the Withdrawal Agreement). It consists of the same sign, covers the same goods and services and retains the filing and priority dates of the EU trademark.

The comparable UK trademark is an independent right. It must be renewed separately with the UKIPO and can be assigned, licensed or challenged independently of the EU trademark. For renewal purposes, it keeps the expiry date of the EU trademark.

EU trademark applications that were still pending on 31 December 2020 were not converted. For these, a UK application retaining the earlier filing date could be filed until 30 September 2021 (Article 59 of the Withdrawal Agreement). This deadline has expired.

Anyone requiring trademark protection in the United Kingdom today must therefore file a UK trademark application with the UKIPO or designate the United Kingdom in an international registration.

A clearance search is used to check whether the trademark for which trademark protection is sought is already registered in a trademark register. This search usually covers not only identical trademarks, but also those that are confusingly similar. In addition, it is also possible to search for identical or confusingly similar trademarks that are not registered in a trademark register but are only used in business transactions. Such signs are often registered as a company name in the commercial register and similar registers (Austria: Firmenbuch). The aim is to avoid conflicts with an identical or similar trademark from the outset. Collision searches can be carried out for trademarks of all kinds, not only those consisting of characters (word trademarks). Depending on the type of search, this can be extensive and therefore more or less costly.
The result of a clearance search can be wide-ranging. The worst-case scenario is the existence of an identical trademark that is also registered for identical goods and/or services. This case generally precludes the registration of the desired trademark and, at best, raises the question of whether the registered trademark can be acquired or – an alternative that is often overlooked – has not been used at all for more than five years (expiration of the grace period).
A typical result is the discovery of similar signs for similar goods and/or services to those for which trademark protection is sought. This result requires a careful analysis of whether the similarity also leads to a likelihood of confusion in the trademark sense.
In our opinion, a clearance search is essential. Anyone who does not carry it out (or have it carried out) is flying blind. If the owner of a conflicting trademark then successfully opposes the trademark or even has it successfully canceled, all the time and money spent on the trademark application will have been wasted. Furthermore, the third party often does not stop at challenging the trademark. In addition to ceasing use of the trademark, they also demand information and accounting of the sales and profits generated in order to claim damages on this basis.

Likelihood of confusion is the central concept of trademark law. It determines whether the owner of an earlier trademark can file an opposition against a later trademark or prohibit its use (Sec. 9(1) no. 2, Sec. 14(2) no. 2 German Trademark Act (MarkenG); Art. 8(1)(b), Art. 9(2)(b) EU Trade Mark Regulation (EUTMR)). There is a likelihood of confusion if the public could believe that the goods or services come from the same undertaking or from economically linked undertakings.

The decisive perspective is that of the average consumer of the goods or services concerned, who is reasonably well informed, observant and circumspect. He or she rarely sees the two marks side by side and has to rely on an imperfect recollection. For everyday goods the level of attention tends to be low; for expensive goods or a professional public it is higher.

Three interdependent factors

Likelihood of confusion is assessed on the basis of three factors that influence one another:

  • the similarity of the signs,
  • the similarity of the goods or services,
  • the distinctiveness of the earlier mark, i.e. its capacity to be remembered by the public as an indication of origin.

A lower degree of one factor may be offset by a higher degree of another. In practice this means:

  • If the goods are identical, even a rather low degree of similarity between the signs may suffice.
  • If the goods are only remotely similar, the signs must be very close to each other.
  • If the earlier mark is inherently original or has been strengthened by intensive use, its protection extends further. If it is based on a descriptive term, its scope of protection is narrow.
  • If the goods or services are not similar at all, there is no likelihood of confusion, even if the signs are identical. In that case only the extended protection of the trademark with a reputation can help.

Similarity of the signs

The signs are compared on the basis of their overall impression, in three respects: phonetically (how they are pronounced), visually (how they look) and conceptually (what they mean). Similarity in one of these respects may already be sufficient. The beginning of a word is usually given more attention than its end.

According to settled case law, the public will generally focus on the word element of a combined word and figurative mark, because it is the simplest way to refer to the mark. A different graphic design therefore often does not rule out a likelihood of confusion. This may be different if the word element is purely descriptive and the figurative element dominates the overall impression. For purely figurative marks, the decisive factors are mainly the motif and a shared meaning. Where a composite sign incorporates an earlier mark, there may be a likelihood of confusion if the earlier mark retains an independent distinctive role within it.

Similarity of goods and services

Whether goods or services are similar depends on their nature, intended purpose, method of use, distribution channels and on whether they are in competition with or complementary to each other. The key question is whether the public assumes that they usually come from the same undertaking. The classes of the Nice Classification are not decisive: goods in the same class may be dissimilar, goods in different classes may be similar.

Forms of likelihood of confusion

Besides direct confusion, where the public mistakes one mark for the other, the law also recognises indirect confusion: the public notices the differences but regards the later mark as another sign from a series of marks belonging to the owner of the earlier mark. Finally, there may be a likelihood of confusion in the broader sense if the public infers economic or organisational links between the undertakings.

A trademark has a reputation if it is known by a significant part of the public concerned by the goods or services it covers. The courts do not require a fixed percentage. All circumstances must be taken into account, in particular market share, intensity, geographical extent and duration of use, and the amount invested in promoting the mark. In practice, reputation is often proven by sales figures, advertising material, press coverage and consumer surveys. Where the public is a specialist one, reputation within that narrow circle may suffice.

For a German trademark, reputation in Germany is decisive; for an EU trademark, reputation in a substantial part of the European Union. Depending on the circumstances, the territory of a single Member State may be sufficient.

Protection across goods and classes

The most important special feature: a trademark with a reputation is protected not only for its own goods and services but also against use for entirely different products (Sec. 9(1) no. 3, Sec. 14(2) no. 3 MarkenG; Art. 8(5), Art. 9(2)(c) EUTMR). No likelihood of confusion is required. It is sufficient that the public makes a mental link between the two signs and that the later mark

  • takes unfair advantage of the repute of the mark with a reputation (free-riding, image transfer),
  • is detrimental to its repute (tarnishment, for example through association with offensive or inferior products), or
  • is detrimental to its distinctive character (dilution, the mark loses its uniqueness),

without due cause. Anyone who uses the name of a well-known car brand for cosmetics, for example, cannot argue that no one would confuse a car with a perfume.

What matters is the reputation at the time the later sign acquired its priority. A reputation acquired only later does not have retroactive effect.

The term “famous trademark” (berühmte Marke) comes from German case law before the Trademark Act entered into force in 1995. At that time, a trademark was in principle protected only for similar goods. For marks with an outstanding position, the courts therefore developed protection under general tort law (Sec. 12, 823, 1004 German Civil Code) against dilution through use for entirely different products.

The requirements were high. A mark was considered famous only if

  • it enjoyed outstanding recognition, not only among the buyers of its goods but among the general public; degrees of recognition well below 80 % were generally not sufficient,
  • it was unique, i.e. not already diluted by similar signs of other undertakings, and
  • it had a special character and enjoyed high esteem.

Today, protection across goods and classes is governed by the Trademark Act under the rules on trademarks with a reputation. A famous trademark is always also a trademark with a reputation. Its protection therefore derives primarily from Sec. 14(2) no. 3 MarkenG. Fame now mainly has an effect of degree: the higher the recognition, the more readily the public will make a mental link even with very different goods, and the easier it is to show free-riding or dilution. In practice, a famous trademark thus extends to almost all fields of goods and services. In addition, protection as a name (Sec. 12 German Civil Code) may remain relevant outside the course of trade, for example in domain name disputes.

A distinction must be made from the well-known mark (Sec. 4 no. 3, Sec. 10 MarkenG, Art. 6bis Paris Convention). It is protected without being registered or used in Germany, because it is generally known in the relevant trade circles. This is particularly helpful for foreign companies whose mark has not yet been registered in Germany.

Trademark protection for German trademarks and EU trademarks arises upon registration in the register of the respective trademark office. The term of protection is ten years, calculated from the filing date, and can be renewed indefinitely for further periods of ten years.

German trademarks: For trademarks registered on or after 14 January 2019, protection ends on the day corresponding to the filing date (e.g. filed on 17 January 2019 – protection ends on 17 January 2029). For trademarks registered up to 13 January 2019, protection still ends at the end of the month in which the filing date falls (e.g. filed on 5 July 2017 – protection ends on 31 July 2027; Section 159(1) German Trademark Act). Payment of the renewal fee is sufficient for a full renewal; it is deemed to be a request for renewal (Section 47(3) German Trademark Act). The fee falls due six months before protection expires.

EU trademarks: Protection always ends on the day corresponding to the filing date (e.g. filed on 16 April 2016 – protection ends on 16 April 2026; Article 52 EUTMR). The end-of-month rule of former German law does not apply to EU trademarks. Renewal must be requested from the EUIPO (Article 53 EUTMR); the request and the fee must be submitted within the six months before protection expires.

In both cases, renewal is still possible within a grace period of six months after expiry, subject to a surcharge. Renewal takes effect from the day following the expiry of the previous term.

A registered trademark confers a monopoly. The law aims to prevent registers from being blocked by marks that nobody uses. Anyone who registers a trademark must therefore also put it to genuine use (Sec. 26 MarkenG; Art. 18 EUTMR).

After registration, there is a grace period of five years. For a German trademark, it begins when the opposition period expires or, if an opposition was filed, when the opposition proceedings are concluded. For an EU trademark, it begins with registration. During this period, the mark does not yet have to be used.

After that, the owner of an unused trademark faces considerable disadvantages:

  • Revocation: Any third party may apply for the cancellation of the mark for non-use, for a German trademark before the German Patent and Trade Mark Office (DPMA) or by court action, for an EU trademark before the EUIPO or by counterclaim (Sec. 49 MarkenG; Art. 58 EUTMR).
  • No claims: The owner cannot take action against infringers if they raise the defence of non-use (Sec. 25 MarkenG).
  • No opposition: In opposition proceedings against a later mark, the applicant may raise the plea of non-use. The opponent must then prove use (Sec. 43 MarkenG; Art. 47(2) EUTMR).

If use begins only after the grace period has expired, revocation can generally still be avoided. This does not apply, however, to use that begins only within three months before an application for revocation, after the owner has learned that such an application is imminent.

Exceptionally, non-use is harmless if there are proper reasons beyond the owner’s control, for example a pending regulatory approval for a medicinal product.

Important in practice: a clearance search that reveals an identical earlier mark is not necessarily the end of the project. If the earlier mark has not been used for more than five years, it can be challenged.

Genuine use is required. It exists if the mark is actually used in accordance with its essential function, namely to create or maintain a market for the registered goods or services. In detail:

  • Directed outwards: Use must take place vis-à-vis customers on the market. Use only within the company or the group of companies is not sufficient (see our article Internal use only – and lost for the market, in German).
  • Not merely token use: Use that serves solely to preserve the rights in the mark is not genuine use.
  • Certain extent: There is no fixed minimum quantity. What matters is an overall assessment: the nature of the goods, the size and characteristics of the market, and the extent, frequency and duration of use. For expensive specialist products, a few sales may suffice; for mass-market goods, small quantities are generally not enough.
  • As a trademark: The sign must be used as an indication of origin for the goods or services, for example on the goods, packaging, in catalogues, on the website or on invoices. Use merely as a company name is not automatically sufficient.
  • For the registered goods: If the mark is registered for a broad general term but has been used only for individual goods, it is maintained only for those goods or a corresponding subcategory. For the rest, it is revoked.
  • In the protected territory: A German trademark must be used in Germany, an EU trademark in the European Union. Affixing the mark in Germany to goods intended exclusively for export also counts as use.
  • In a modified form: Minor differences between the form used and the registered form are harmless as long as they do not alter the distinctive character of the mark. A modernisation of the logo may therefore be permissible, a fundamental redesign may not.
  • Also by third parties: Use by a licensee or another person with the owner’s consent counts as use by the owner.

In the event of a dispute, use must be proven for the relevant five-year period. Suitable evidence includes invoices, catalogues, price lists, advertising material, photographs of products and packaging, dated website printouts and affidavits stating sales figures. Collecting such evidence on an ongoing basis saves a laborious and often incomplete search when it matters.

When a new application is filed, the trademark office does not examine whether earlier marks stand in its way. It is up to the trademark owner to defend his or her rights. This is the purpose of ongoing trademark monitoring.

Register monitoring

A specialised watch service regularly compares the publications of new trademark applications and registrations in the relevant registers with the owner’s mark, for example at the DPMA, the EUIPO and WIPO for international registrations, and in other countries where necessary. The search covers not only identical but also similar signs in identical or similar fields of goods and services. The hits are then assessed by a lawyer: is the distance sufficient, or is there a likelihood of confusion?

Timing is crucial. An opposition against a later mark can be filed within three months; for a German trademark from publication of the registration, for an EU trademark from publication of the application. An opposition is considerably cheaper and faster than later cancellation or infringement proceedings. If the deadline is missed, only the more laborious route remains.

Market monitoring

The market should also be kept in view: online marketplaces, search engines, social networks, new domain names and commercial register entries. Many infringements are committed with signs that have not been filed as trademarks at all but are simply used.

Why monitoring matters

  • Anyone who knowingly tolerates the use of a later registered trademark for five consecutive years loses his or her claims against it (acquiescence, Sec. 21 MarkenG; Art. 61 EUTMR).
  • Every similar sign that goes unchallenged weakens one’s own mark and narrows its scope of protection.
  • Against imported counterfeits, an application for customs action can be filed, so that customs will detain suspicious goods.

Ongoing maintenance also includes

  • monitoring one’s own renewal deadlines,
  • checking whether the mark is still used for all registered goods,
  • collecting evidence of use on an ongoing basis.

A basic distinction is made between word marks, word/figurative marks, and figurative marks.
However, there are also sound marks (e.g., jingles and theme tunes), color marks, and 3D marks, film sequences as motion marks, cable identification marks, position marks, and hologram marks. The list is not exhaustive.
Olfactory trademarks (smell trademarks) have not yet proven to be registrable.

The German trademark, also known as a DE trademark, grants protection within the territory of the Federal Republic of Germany.
If you intend to label your products or services uniformly within the EU, you can apply to the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) in Alicante, Spain, for registration of a European Union trademark, which will then be valid throughout the entire territory of the European Union.
However, not only the owner of an earlier EU trademark, but also the owner of a national trademark from an EU country or the owner of an international trademark with protection in an EU country is entitled to file an opposition. If the opposition is successful, your trademark will be refused registration for the entire EU. Applications for EU trademarks can be filed directly with the EUIPO or with the DPMA.
If you wish to extend your trademark protection further, you can register your national trademark internationally with the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), which is responsible for this procedure. In this case, the priority of your national trademark, which is referred to as the “basic trademark” in this context, may apply. This allows you to claim trademark protection in almost 120 countries, including European countries as well as countries in the Americas, Asia, and Africa. In the countries you designate, the international registration, known as an “IR trademark,” is treated like a national trademark application.

The official fees for registering a German trademark are at least €290.00. Details can be found on the DPMA website. The registration of a “European trademark,” correctly referred to as a European Union trademark, is subject to official fees of at least €850.00. Details can also be found on the EUIPO website. The costs for the international registration of a German or European trademark (which then form the basic trademark) are generally based on the number of countries to which the trademark protection is to be extended. If the international registration is based on a German basic trademark, official fees of €180 are payable to the DPMA. Further information on IR trademarks can be found on the website of the World Intellectual Property Organization, WIPO.

In addition, there are legal consulting fees. A solid trademark application should be accompanied by a clearance search, and the choice of goods and service classes, including the goods and services contained therein, must meet certain requirements. Anyone who does not have the necessary expertise should seek legal assistance.